Create Jira Epic

This skill provides implementation guidance for creating well-structured Jira epics that organize related stories and tasks into cohesive bodies of work.

When to Use This Skill

This skill is automatically invoked by the /jira:create epic command to guide the epic creation process.

Prerequisites

• MCP Jira server configured and accessible
• User has permissions to create issues in the target project
• Understanding of the epic scope and related work

What is an Epic?

An agile epic is:

• A body of work that can be broken down into specific items (stories/tasks)
• Based on the needs/requests of customers or end-users
• An important practice for agile and DevOps teams
• A tool to manage work at a higher level than individual stories

Epic Characteristics

Epics should:

• Be more narrow than a market problem or feature
• Be broader than a user story
• Fit inside a time box (quarter/release)
• Stories within the epic should fit inside a sprint
• Include acceptance criteria that define when the epic is done

Epic vs Feature vs Story

Level	Scope	Duration	Example
Feature	Strategic objective, market problem	Multiple releases	"Advanced cluster observability"
Epic	Specific capability, narrower than feature	One quarter/release	"Multi-cluster metrics aggregation"
Story	Single user-facing functionality	One sprint	"As an SRE, I want to view metrics from multiple clusters in one dashboard"

Epic Name Field Requirement

IMPORTANT: Many Jira configurations require the epic name field to be set.

• Epic Name = Summary (should be identical)
• This is a separate required field in addition to the summary field
• If epic name is missing, epic creation will fail

MCP Tool Handling:

• Some projects auto-populate epic name from summary
• Some require explicit epic name field
• Always set epic name = summary to ensure compatibility

Epic Description Best Practices

Clear Objective

The epic description should:

• State the overall goal or objective
• Explain the value or benefit
• Identify the target users or stakeholders
• Define the scope (what's included and excluded)

Good example:

Enable administrators to manage multiple hosted control plane clusters from a single observability dashboard.

This epic delivers unified metrics aggregation, alerting, and visualization across clusters, reducing the operational overhead of managing multiple cluster environments.

Target users: SREs, Platform administrators

Acceptance Criteria for Epics

Epic-level acceptance criteria define when the epic is complete:

Format:

h2. Epic Acceptance Criteria

* <High-level outcome 1>
* <High-level outcome 2>
* <High-level outcome 3>

Example:

h2. Epic Acceptance Criteria

* Administrators can view aggregated metrics from all clusters in a single dashboard
* Alert rules can be configured to fire based on cross-cluster conditions
* Historical metrics are retained for 30 days across all clusters
* Documentation is complete for multi-cluster setup and configuration

Characteristics:

• Broader than story AC (focus on overall capability, not implementation details)
• Measurable outcomes
• User-observable (not technical implementation)
• Typically 3-6 criteria (if more, consider splitting epic)

Timeboxing

Include timeframe information:

• Target quarter or release
• Key milestones or dependencies
• Known constraints

Example:

h2. Timeline

* Target: Q1 2025 / OpenShift 4.21
* Milestone 1: Metrics collection infrastructure (Sprint 1-2)
* Milestone 2: Dashboard and visualization (Sprint 3-4)
* Milestone 3: Alerting and historical data (Sprint 5-6)

Parent Link to Feature

If the epic belongs to a larger feature:

• Link to parent feature using --parent flag
• Explain how this epic contributes to the feature
• Reference feature key in description

Example:

h2. Parent Feature

This epic is part of [PROJ-100] "Advanced cluster observability" and specifically addresses the multi-cluster aggregation capability.

Interactive Epic Collection Workflow

When creating an epic, guide the user through:

1. Epic Objective

Prompt: "What is the main objective or goal of this epic? What capability will it deliver?"

Helpful questions:

• What is the overall goal?
• What high-level capability will be delivered?
• Who will benefit from this epic?

Example response:

Enable SREs to manage and monitor multiple ROSA HCP clusters from a unified observability dashboard, reducing the operational complexity of multi-cluster environments.

2. Epic Scope

Prompt: "What is included in this epic? What is explicitly out of scope?"

Helpful questions:

• What functionality is included?
• What related work is NOT part of this epic?
• Where are the boundaries?

Example response:

In scope:
- Metrics aggregation from multiple clusters
- Unified dashboard for cluster health
- Cross-cluster alerting
- 30-day historical metrics retention

Out of scope:
- Log aggregation (separate epic)
- Cost reporting (different feature)
- Support for non-HCP clusters (future work)

3. Epic Acceptance Criteria

Prompt: "What are the high-level outcomes that define this epic as complete?"

Guidance:

• Focus on capabilities, not implementation
• Should be measurable/demonstrable
• Typically 3-6 criteria

Example response:

- SREs can view aggregated metrics from all managed clusters in one dashboard
- Alert rules can be defined for cross-cluster conditions (e.g., "any cluster CPU >80%")
- Historical metrics available for 30 days
- Configuration documented and tested

4. Timeframe

Prompt: "What is the target timeframe for this epic? (quarter, release, or estimated sprints)"

Example responses:

• "Q1 2025"
• "OpenShift 4.21"
• "Estimate 6 sprints"
• "Must complete by March 2025"

5. Parent Feature (Optional)

Prompt: "Is this epic part of a larger feature? If yes, provide the feature key."

If yes:

• Validate parent exists
• Confirm parent is a Feature (not another Epic)
• Link epic to parent

Field Validation

Before submitting the epic, validate:

Required Fields

• ✅ Summary is clear and describes the capability
• ✅ Epic name field is set (same as summary)
• ✅ Description includes objective
• ✅ Epic acceptance criteria present
• ✅ Timeframe specified
• ✅ Component is specified (if required by project)
• ✅ Target version is set (if required by project)

Epic Quality

• ✅ Scope is broader than a story, narrower than a feature
• ✅ Can fit in a quarter/release timeframe
• ✅ Has measurable acceptance criteria
• ✅ Clearly identifies target users/stakeholders
• ✅ Defines what's in scope and out of scope

Parent Validation (if specified)

• ✅ Parent issue exists
• ✅ Parent is a Feature (not Epic or Story)
• ✅ Epic contributes to parent's objective

Security

• ✅ No credentials, API keys, or secrets in any field

MCP Tool Parameters

Basic Epic Creation

mcp__atlassian__jira_create_issue(
    project_key="<PROJECT_KEY>",
    summary="<epic summary>",
    issue_type="Epic",
    description="""
<Epic objective and description>

h2. Epic Acceptance Criteria

* <Outcome 1>
* <Outcome 2>
* <Outcome 3>

h2. Scope

h3. In Scope
* <What's included>

h3. Out of Scope
* <What's not included>

h2. Timeline

Target: <quarter/release>
    """,
    components="<component name>",  # if required
    additional_fields={
        "customfield_epicname": "<epic name>",  # if required, same as summary
        # Add other project-specific fields
    }
)

With Project-Specific Fields (e.g., CNTRLPLANE)

mcp__atlassian__jira_create_issue(
    project_key="CNTRLPLANE",
    summary="Multi-cluster metrics aggregation for ROSA HCP",
    issue_type="Epic",
    description="""
Enable SREs to manage and monitor multiple ROSA HCP clusters from a unified observability dashboard, reducing operational complexity of multi-cluster environments.

h2. Epic Acceptance Criteria

* SREs can view aggregated metrics from all managed clusters in one dashboard
* Alert rules can be defined for cross-cluster conditions (e.g., "any cluster CPU >80%")
* Historical metrics retained for 30 days across all clusters
* Multi-cluster setup documented and tested with production workloads
* Performance acceptable with 100+ clusters

h2. Scope

h3. In Scope
* Metrics aggregation across ROSA HCP clusters
* Unified dashboard for cluster health and performance
* Cross-cluster alerting capabilities
* 30-day historical metrics retention
* Configuration via CLI and API

h3. Out of Scope
* Log aggregation (separate epic CNTRLPLANE-200)
* Cost reporting (different feature)
* Support for standalone OCP clusters (future consideration)
* Integration with external monitoring systems (post-MVP)

h2. Timeline

* Target: Q1 2025 / OpenShift 4.21
* Estimated: 6 sprints
* Key milestone: MVP dashboard by end of Sprint 3

h2. Target Users

* SREs managing multiple ROSA HCP clusters
* Platform administrators
* Operations teams

h2. Dependencies

* Requires centralized metrics storage infrastructure ([CNTRLPLANE-150])
* Depends on cluster registration API ([CNTRLPLANE-175])
    """,
    components="HyperShift / ROSA",
    additional_fields={
        "customfield_12319940": "openshift-4.21",  # target version
        "customfield_epicname": "Multi-cluster metrics aggregation for ROSA HCP",  # epic name
        "labels": ["ai-generated-jira", "observability"],
        "security": {"name": "Red Hat Employee"}
    }
)

With Parent Feature

mcp__atlassian__jira_create_issue(
    project_key="MYPROJECT",
    summary="Multi-cluster monitoring dashboard",
    issue_type="Epic",
    description="<epic content>",
    additional_fields={
        "customfield_epicname": "Multi-cluster monitoring dashboard",
        "parent": {"key": "MYPROJECT-100"}  # link to parent feature
    }
)

Jira Description Formatting

Use Jira's native formatting (Wiki markup):

Epic Template Format

<Epic objective - what capability will be delivered and why it matters>

h2. Epic Acceptance Criteria

* <High-level outcome 1>
* <High-level outcome 2>
* <High-level outcome 3>

h2. Scope

h3. In Scope
* <Functionality included in this epic>
* <Capabilities to be delivered>

h3. Out of Scope
* <Related work NOT in this epic>
* <Future considerations>

h2. Timeline

* Target: <quarter or release>
* Estimated: <sprints>
* Key milestones: <major deliverables>

h2. Target Users

* <User group 1>
* <User group 2>

h2. Dependencies (optional)

* [PROJ-XXX] - <dependency description>

h2. Parent Feature (if applicable)

This epic is part of [PROJ-YYY] "<feature name>" and addresses <how this epic contributes>.

Error Handling

Epic Name Field Missing

Scenario: Epic creation fails due to missing epic name field.

Action:

1. Check if project requires epic name field
2. If required, set customfield_epicname = summary
3. Retry creation

Note: Field ID may vary by Jira instance:

• customfield_epicname (common)
• customfield_10011 (numbered field)
• Check project configuration if standard field names don't work

Epic Too Large

Scenario: Epic seems too large (would take >1 quarter).

Action:

1. Suggest splitting into multiple epics
2. Identify natural split points
3. Consider if this should be a Feature instead

Example:

This epic seems quite large (estimated 12+ sprints). Consider:

Option 1: Split into multiple epics
- Epic 1: Core metrics aggregation (sprints 1-6)
- Epic 2: Advanced dashboards and alerting (sprints 7-12)

Option 2: Create as Feature instead
- This might be better as a Feature with multiple child Epics

Which would you prefer?

Epic Too Small

Scenario: Epic could be completed in one sprint.

Action:

1. Suggest creating as a Story instead
2. Explain epic should be multi-sprint effort

Example:

This epic seems small enough to be a single Story (completable in one sprint).

Epics should typically:
- Span multiple sprints (2-8 sprints)
- Contain multiple stories
- Deliver a cohesive capability

Would you like to create this as a Story instead? (yes/no)

Parent Not a Feature

Scenario: User specifies parent, but it's not a Feature.

Action:

1. Check parent issue type
2. If parent is Epic or Story, inform user
3. Suggest correction

Example:

Parent issue PROJ-100 is an Epic, but epics should typically link to Features (not other Epics).

Options:
1. Link to the parent Feature instead (if PROJ-100 has a parent)
2. Proceed without parent link
3. Create a Feature first, then link this Epic to it

What would you like to do?

Missing Acceptance Criteria

Scenario: User doesn't provide epic acceptance criteria.

Action:

1. Explain importance of epic AC
2. Ask probing questions
3. Help construct AC

Example:

Epic acceptance criteria help define when this epic is complete. Let's add some.

What are the key outcomes that must be achieved?
- What capabilities will exist when this epic is done?
- How will you demonstrate the epic is complete?
- What must work end-to-end?

Example: "Administrators can view aggregated metrics from all clusters"

Security Validation Failure

Scenario: Sensitive data detected in epic content.

Action:

1. STOP submission
2. Inform user what type of data was detected
3. Ask for redaction

MCP Tool Error

Scenario: MCP tool returns an error when creating the epic.

Action:

1. Parse error message
2. Provide user-friendly explanation
3. Suggest corrective action

Common errors:

• "Field 'epic name' is required" → Set epic name = summary
• "Invalid parent" → Verify parent is Feature type
• "Issue type 'Epic' not available" → Check if project supports Epics

Examples

Example 1: Epic with Full Details

Input:

/jira:create epic CNTRLPLANE "Multi-cluster metrics aggregation"

Interactive prompts:

What is the main objective of this epic?
> Enable SREs to monitor multiple ROSA HCP clusters from one dashboard

What is included in scope?
> Metrics aggregation, unified dashboard, cross-cluster alerting, 30-day retention

What is out of scope?
> Log aggregation, cost reporting, non-HCP cluster support

Epic acceptance criteria?
> - View aggregated metrics from all clusters
> - Configure cross-cluster alerts
> - 30-day historical retention
> - Complete documentation

Timeframe?
> Q1 2025, estimate 6 sprints

Parent feature? (optional)
> CNTRLPLANE-100

Result:

• Epic created with complete description
• Linked to parent feature
• All CNTRLPLANE conventions applied

Example 2: Epic with Auto-Detection

Input:

/jira:create epic CNTRLPLANE "Advanced node pool autoscaling for ARO HCP"

Auto-applied (via cntrlplane skill):

• Component: HyperShift / ARO (detected from "ARO HCP")
• Target Version: openshift-4.21
• Epic Name: Same as summary
• Labels: ai-generated-jira
• Security: Red Hat Employee

Interactive prompts:

• Epic objective and scope
• Acceptance criteria
• Timeframe

Result:

• Full epic with ARO component

Example 3: Standalone Epic (No Parent)

Input:

/jira:create epic MYPROJECT "Improve test coverage for API endpoints"

Result:

• Epic created without parent
• Standard epic fields applied
• Ready for stories to be linked

Best Practices Summary

1. Clear objective: State what capability will be delivered
2. Define scope: Explicitly state what's in and out of scope
3. Epic AC: High-level outcomes that define "done"
4. Right size: 2-8 sprints, fits in a quarter
5. Timebox: Specify target quarter/release
6. Link to feature: If part of larger initiative
7. Target users: Identify who benefits
8. Epic name field: Always set (same as summary)

Anti-Patterns to Avoid

❌ Epic is actually a story

"As a user, I want to view a dashboard"

✅ Too small, create as Story instead

❌ Epic is actually a feature

"Complete observability platform redesign" (12 months, 50+ stories)

✅ Too large, create as Feature with child Epics

❌ Vague acceptance criteria

- Epic is done when everything works

✅ Be specific: "SREs can view metrics from 100+ clusters with <1s load time"

❌ Implementation details in AC

- Backend uses PostgreSQL for metrics storage
- API implements gRPC endpoints

✅ Focus on outcomes, not implementation

❌ No scope definition

Description: "Improve monitoring"

✅ Define what's included and what's not

Workflow Summary

1. ✅ Parse command arguments (project, summary, flags)
2. 🔍 Auto-detect component from summary keywords
3. ⚙️ Apply project-specific defaults
4. 💬 Interactively collect epic objective and scope
5. 💬 Interactively collect epic acceptance criteria
6. 💬 Collect timeframe and parent link (if applicable)
7. 🔒 Scan for sensitive data
8. ✅ Validate epic size and quality
9. ✅ Set epic name field = summary
10. 📝 Format description with Jira markup
11. ✅ Create epic via MCP tool
12. 📤 Return issue key and URL

See Also

• /jira:create - Main command that invokes this skill
• create-feature skill - For larger strategic initiatives
• create-story skill - For stories within epics
• cntrlplane skill - CNTRLPLANE specific conventions
• Agile epic management best practices