MCP HubMCP Hub
← スキル一覧に戻る

critique

majiayu000
更新日 Today
22 閲覧
58
9
58
GitHubで表示
テストgeneral

について

`critique`スキルは、プロジェクトアイデアに対して懐疑的かつベンチャーキャピタリスト風の評価を提供し、前提条件に疑問を投げかけ、弱点を特定します。ユーザーが検証を依頼したり「これは良いアイデアですか？」と問い合わせた際に、プロジェクト概要を分析し、市場的・技術的・事業的実現可能性を評価します。このスキルは、構造化された批評を指定されたプロジェクトフォルダに出力し、開発者によるレビューに供します。

クイックインストール

Claude Code

推奨
プラグインコマンド推奨
/plugin add https://github.com/majiayu000/claude-skill-registry
Git クローン代替
git clone https://github.com/majiayu000/claude-skill-registry.git ~/.claude/skills/critique

このコマンドをClaude Codeにコピー＆ペーストしてスキルをインストールします

ドキュメント

/critique

Skeptical, VC-style evaluation of a project idea.

Usage

/critique                        # Critique current project
/critique --project coordinatr   # Specific project
/critique --focus market         # Market validation focus
/critique --focus technical      # Technical feasibility focus
/critique --focus business       # Business model focus

Output Location

ideas/[project]/critiques/YYYY-MM-DD.md

Prerequisites

REQUIRED: project-brief.md must exist

ls ideas/{project}/project-brief.md
# If missing: "Run /brief first"

Execution Flow

1. Load Project Context

Read: ideas/{project}/project-brief.md
Read: ideas/{project}/competitive-analysis.md (if exists)
Read: ideas/{project}/README.md
Glob: resources/research/*.md

2. Invoke idea-critic Agent

Analysis areas:

  1. Problem Validity - Is this a real problem? Evidence?
  2. Market Opportunity - Size? Timing? Competition?
  3. Solution Fit - Does solution address root cause?
  4. Differentiation - Why will this win?
  5. Business Model - Revenue? Unit economics?
  6. Execution Risk - Team? Timeline? Resources?
  7. Technical Feasibility - Can this be built?

3. Generate Critique Document

---
created: YYYY-MM-DD
verdict: strong | promising | needs_work | reconsider
confidence: high | medium | low
---

# Critique: [Project Name]

## Executive Summary
[Honest 1-2 paragraph assessment]

## Critical Concerns

### High Priority
1. **[Concern]**: [Why concerning]
   - Evidence needed: [What would resolve]

### Medium Priority
1. **[Concern]**: [Why matters]
   - Suggestion: [How to address]

### Strengths
1. **[Strength]**: [Why valuable]

## Analysis by Area
[Problem Validity, Market, Solution Fit, etc.]

## Hard Questions to Answer
1. [Tough question]
2. [Another challenge]

## Recommendations

### If You Proceed
- [De-risk action]
- [Research needed]

### If You Pivot
- [Alternative direction]

Focus Modes

--focus market

  • Market size/dynamics
  • Competition landscape
  • Customer validation
  • Timing and trends

--focus technical

  • Technical feasibility
  • Architecture complexity
  • Skill requirements

--focus business

  • Revenue model
  • Pricing strategy
  • Unit economics
  • Go-to-market

When to Use

  • After completing project brief
  • Before significant time investment
  • When seeking honest feedback
  • Before presenting to others

Not for: Ideas still forming (use /brief), when needing encouragement

Workflow

/brief -> /critique -> /research -> /spec

GitHub リポジトリ

majiayu000/claude-skill-registry
パス: skills/critique

関連スキル

algorithmic-art

メタ

This Claude Skill creates original algorithmic art using p5.js with seeded randomness and interactive parameters. It generates .md files for algorithmic philosophies, plus .html and .js files for interactive generative art implementations. Use it when developers need to create flow fields, particle systems, or other computational art while avoiding copyright issues.

スキルを見る

subagent-driven-development

開発

This skill executes implementation plans by dispatching a fresh subagent for each independent task, with code review between tasks. It enables fast iteration while maintaining quality gates through this review process. Use it when working on mostly independent tasks within the same session to ensure continuous progress with built-in quality checks.

スキルを見る

executing-plans

デザイン

Use the executing-plans skill when you have a complete implementation plan to execute in controlled batches with review checkpoints. It loads and critically reviews the plan, then executes tasks in small batches (default 3 tasks) while reporting progress between each batch for architect review. This ensures systematic implementation with built-in quality control checkpoints.

スキルを見る

cost-optimization

その他

This Claude Skill helps developers optimize cloud costs through resource rightsizing, tagging strategies, and spending analysis. It provides a framework for reducing cloud expenses and implementing cost governance across AWS, Azure, and GCP. Use it when you need to analyze infrastructure costs, right-size resources, or meet budget constraints.

スキルを見る